Why Ad Performance Now Depends Upon 70–80% On Creatives?

Creative or Data? The Truth About What Really Drives Ad Performance | Ft. Charlotte | WMH | Ep.10

Creative content now drives 70-80% of advertising success on...

Creative content now drives 70-80% of advertising success on platforms like Meta, whereas technical factors such as bidding strategies and targeting have become less critical due to automation.

Meta’s algorithms increasingly favor broad audiences over interest targeting, requiring advertisers to focus on creating diverse, micro-personalized creatives that resonate deeply with niche audience segments.

The upcoming Andromeda algorithm rollout in July demands higher volumes and greater diversity of creatives, making small variations insufficient.

This shift requires advertisers to produce a variety of messages and visuals tailored to specific customer pain points and scenarios.

Stricter advertising policies, especially around discriminatory content, have been enforced since August, causing more frequent ad rejections and complicating campaign management.

Advertisers face operational challenges due to platform glitches and frequent changes in campaign setups, which disrupt established workflows and increase time and effort to launch ads.

Many clients are slow or reluctant to provide quality creative materials, leading some advertisers to experiment with AI-generated avatars and creative tools, though these often remain too broad or cliché.

Despite the availability of innovative creative tools, strategic messaging based on deep audience understanding remains paramount.

Creatives must reflect psychographic profiles, emotional triggers, and specific pain points to convert effectively.

Charlotte introduces the ACES Method for creative strategy, a systematic process involving:

A: Audience Understanding: In-depth insight into demographics, pain points, motivations, identity, and emotional drivers.

C: Concepts: Leveraging proven creative frameworks like “us versus them,” benefits call-outs, testimonials, and storytelling structures (e.g., PAS, AIDA).

E: Execution: Launching campaigns and collecting performance data.

S: Systematic Testing: Rigorous tracking, labeling, and iterative optimization based on data rather than intuition.

Innovation in creative ads is useful but should be approached cautiously because untested ideas can incur high production costs without guaranteed ROI.

Testing new concepts organically first is recommended before investing heavily in paid ads.

Final Advice from the Charlotte

She highlights the balance between creative innovation and data-driven strategy, especially for media buyers who may be more analytical than creative.

Prioritize deep audience research to understand pain points, motivations, and identities before developing creatives.

Use proven creative frameworks to streamline ad creation and improve performance reliability.